Employers leveraging AI as their first level resource for employment agreements and policies are generating oddities that employment lawyers then need to set straight. These are not simply rookie-level mistakes, but rather combobulations of disparate concepts and approaches, moshing together incredibly specific elements that exceed legal requirements with vague references to complying with “applicable federal, state or local laws” that are used so gratuitously as to be meaningless. While seeking final sign-off from legal counsel is wise, often the corrections required create more work, at the employer’s expense, than if the employer had first gone straight to an experienced attorney for advice.
Employers, you can do better. What follows are my top 5 suggestions for how to reduce legal expenses and leverage AI beneficially in employment situations.
#1 Identify the Issue First
Before seeking legal or other advice, think through and write down the problem you are trying to solve.  If you need help with an employment or separation agreement, is it to add or change specific terms, to simplify an existing template without altering any legally necessary provisions, or to update it to reflect organizational changes or recent legal developments? Do you have a term sheet of provisions that have been agreed to or that you are proposing to offer?
If your focus is on employment policies, are you looking to create or update an entire employee handbook or just add or modify a few policies? Are you starting from scratch or modifying an existing document? Beyond legal requirements, what position do you want to take on standards of conduct and workplace expectations, and what benefits do you want to offer?
Thinking through those questions in advance can shorten the time (and expense) of your consultation with legal counsel and produce a first draft that aligns with your objectives. The executive director of one nonprofit client of mine would bundle the issues to be discussed with me and send an agenda in advance. Thanks to her advance preparation, she was focused in discussing the challenges she was looking to solve and used my time to maximum efficiency.
#2 Ask AI for Examples
In the same way that you might collect samples of style or decorating ideas from online sources, an employer can ask AI for examples of employment agreements or handbook policies. Those queries can even be tailored to a particular industry or employer of a particular size. Because state laws can factor heavily into the language required in an employment-related agreement or handbook, particularly for employers in the northeast, the west coast, Illinois, Colorado and Minnesota, referencing the particular states as part of the query may produce a more appropriately representative sample of documents.
Notably, the purpose of these queries should be educational for the employer, to develop an understanding of the types of provisions the employer may or may not want to ask a lawyer to include in the employer’s own employment documentation. Do not become too wed to any single clause or policy, because a lawyer may advise that legal requirements preclude taking that approach in the applicable jurisdiction, or the language may conflict with other policy statements or contractual commitments that the employer has made.
#3 Consider Confidentiality When Asking AI for Help
Feeding AI legal advice to double-check your lawyer is the legal equivalent of asking a friend or mentor about the guidance a lawyer provided. Once shared with a third party, the legal advice is no longer protected by attorney-client privilege. Worse still, while your friend may not recall the conversation in sufficient detail to confirm that you did or did not disclose privileged information, the AI creates a written, discoverable record of your query that can be used against the employer in future litigation. It is, therefore, better for an employer to frame AI queries in general terms, ideally using enterprise-level AI tools for which the employer holds licenses that assure the queries will not be used to train the AI or for other purposes.
#4 Let Your Lawyer Know What You Queried and Received from AI
AI did not go to law school and I do not expect AI to produce a legally correct and effectively written document. I do, however, hold lawyers to a different standard. If I am asked to review a document that may be technically correct under the law but seems overly cumbersome, too vague, or reflective of a distinctly minority approach to a particular subject, as a matter of professional courtesy, I will hesitate before making revisions. That hesitation and the time I may spend double-checking the legal standard to determine whether the provision that struck me as off is really okay legally, equate to additional legal expense charged to the employer.
Similarly, I have had the experience of a client sending me a list of select employment policies and recommendations for modifications with legal citations, where the recommendations in my view were overly conservative or not reflective of other policies or agreements the employer had in place that effectively addressed the same legal concern. I spent time explaining why those listed changes were optional but not what I would recommend, subsumed by other provisions, or simply incorrect, which created unnecessary expense for the employer.
These days, I have learned to ask clients where the information they have sent is coming from. A quick call to learn that AI was playing lawyer enables me to verbally dispense with many of the AI tool’s recommendations in a more short-hand manner than I could if the recommendations came from the client’s general in-house or outside legal counsel.
#5 Use AI to Make It Pretty
AI does make pretty tables. It can assist with formatting, contrasting fonts and indentations, and other call-outs to make an employee handbook more user-friendly. As noted in point 3, you should not feed the AI any confidential information, and certainly not any privileged legal advice. The organization may however determine that it is comfortable, for example, asking AI to create a table reflecting the accrual periods for paid time off. The entirety of a handbook or employment agreement template may be run through AI for reformatting if the organization has an enterprise-level account that assures confidentiality, although it is best to confirm that approach in advance with legal counsel.
*******
AI can be a huge timesaver and really helpful in educating employers. For draftsmanship, though, often it is more cost effective for an employer to consult with legal counsel first. Attorneys, particularly those who have been practicing in employment law for several years, have usually developed their own legally-compliant templates that start as the baseline for responding to clients’ requests. Those efficiencies help reduce legal fees while providing more legally appropriate employment-related documentation than an AI-generated product.
By Tracey I. Levy

